“Have you seen my baseball?” If you know that line, you know exactly who we are talking about today. Warren is the lovable, eccentric brother from the hit 90s comedy *There’s Something About Mary*.
This costume is instantly recognizable to fans of the movie and incredibly fun to wear. It relies on bright, clashing colors and very specific accessories to work effectively.
You do not need to be a sewing expert to put this look together. Most of these items can be found in a thrift store or your own closet. Let’s get you ready to find Mary.
Complete Costume Breakdown
Clothing & Core Pieces
Start with the most important piece: the varsity jacket. You need a bright fire-red letterman jacket with white striped trim. The color needs to pop, so avoid dark burgundies or dull reds.
Underneath the jacket, Warren wears a very specific graphic tee. Look for a gold or mustard yellow t-shirt featuring a Rubik’s Cube design. This vintage touch is a crucial detail for accuracy.
For the pants, you want classic 90s dad vibes. A pair of medium to dark stonewash jeans with a relaxed fit is perfect. Levi’s 550s are the gold standard here for that authentic baggy look.
Accessories & Details
The accessories truly make this character come alive. You absolutely cannot be Warren without his signature red earmuffs. He wears them constantly, indoors and outdoors, so keep them on all night.
Your main prop will be a standard baseball. Carry it with you everywhere and ask people if they have seen it. It is a simple interactive element that makes the cosplay hilarious.
Finish the look with basic white sneakers. Nothing too flashy or modern; classic tennis shoes work best. A simple backpack slung over one shoulder adds to the youthful, on-the-go vibe.
Cosplay Tips
Comfort is key with this outfit. Since you are wearing a jacket and earmuffs, it can get warm indoors. Wear a light t-shirt underneath so you don’t overheat at a crowded party.
If you can’t find the exact Rubik’s cube shirt, a plain yellow tee works in a pinch. However, the graphic adds that extra layer of authenticity that fans appreciate.
Keep your hair messy and unstyled. Warren doesn’t spend time grooming, so a bedhead look works perfectly here. If your hair is too neat, mess it up with some texture paste.
Character Vibe & Styling Notes
Warren is innocent, easily excitable, and very protective. When posing for photos, look slightly confused or intensely focused on your baseball.
You aren’t trying to look cool or heroic here. Stand with a slouch or clutch your backpack straps. The more candid and unposed you look, the more like Warren you become.
Final Thoughts
This Warren costume is a comedy classic that always gets a laugh. It is perfect for a duo costume if you have a friend playing Mary or Ted. Get your red jacket ready and go find your baseball!
